Some considerations for each method are listed below.
Chemical Fragmentation
Suitable for fragmentation of RNA. Typically, heat is applied to RNA in the presence of a divalent metal cation (for example, magnesium or zinc). The length of the resulting fragments can be adjusted by modifying the incubation time.
Enzymatic Fragmentation
A cost-effective alternative to mechanical shearing methods. Depending on the approach, you may expect some amount of sequencing bias, as many enzymatic methods are influenced by sequence context.
Mechanical Fragmentation
Methods include sonication, acoustic shearing, needle shearing, nebulization, and others. Acoustic shearing generally has the tightest size distribution and introduces the least amount of bias compared to other methods. However, some investment in capital equipment is required. Mechanical methods can introduce DNA damage, and you might consider repair methods as part of your library construction process.
Note
Some sample types (for example, amplicons smaller than 300 bp) or applications (for example, small RNA, cfDNA) do not require fragmentation.